Girl Shy
“…and we were playing this weird finger game on the way to New York and I said screw it, and I grabbed his hand”
It was three thirty in the morning. No one in the house was awake except for me. I lay on my oversized couch, which I had commandeered as my bed for the night. My television displayed a black and white silent film called “Girl Shy”. The film told the story of a boy who was afraid of girls because he of a horrible stutter he had Somehow the boy develops the capacity to write a book about capturing a girl’s heart despite his nonexistent experience with girl. Upon publishing this book he falls himself falling in love with the girl of his dreams. It was pretty heavy stuff, especially for a silent movie, but to my surprise it was a comedy. Of course “Girl Shy” only had part of my attention that night; the girl at the other end of my telephone was expressing her boy troubles to me. As she did so, I wondered when I became so pathetic that my idea of a fun Saturday night was watching an old silent film at three thirty in the morning, and giving a girl who I had the dearest crush on, advice on getting a guy who simply wasn’t right for her.
“Go on…”
I realized that when girls talk about their relationship problems they enter into an extremely volatile and frenzied state. To prevent triggering that volatility, it’s best to simply let them get everything out first before making any remarks. Besides, the only reason why someone would call me at three thirty in the morning was to hear what they wanted to hear from somebody who they thought cared about them. In order to do this, I would have to hear the whole story first.
“He then grabbed my hand, and I swelled up with emotion, it was the greatest feeling in the world, and then casually we started talking to people, hand in hand”
When someone talks about their relationship problems, they always preface their troubles with the good. The reason for this is quite simple, the person expressing the problem wants ever so dearly to hang onto the good memories of that relationship, thus they use their good moments as a means to justify their feelings. What people never realize is that a few moments of the emotional blitz called love, simply cannot justify the ensuing pain and suffering that comes with whatever problems they are facing.
“So what happened after that?”
I looked at my television to see the main character in “Girl Shy” writing a chapter in his book. The title of the chapter was “Situation Number 12: Dealing with Vampires” and as the main character writes the first sentences of the chapter he starts by saying “When dealing with vampires the best thing to do is to approach them with INDIFFERENCE”. I chuckled slightly, for a movie made in the nineteen twenties; “Girl Shy” certainly had a lot of wit and humor.
“Well then we got to New York, and things were pretty casual after that. I kind of assumed that he liked me and everything, especially since we held hands, so I wasn’t afraid to be more open towards him.”
“What do you mean by more open?”
“I mean, I wasn’t so conservative around him, and made it pretty obvious that I liked him. Not that we did really did anything aside from holding hands that one time”
A quandary that I never understood was why emotions had to be hidden. For such exhilarating and joyful emotions as “love” or even “attraction” one would think that the most logical thing to do would be to openly express these positive emotions. Instead, these feelings come tacked on with an abundance of negative connotations. A person always confesses their love instead of simply affirming it. When a relationship ends it’s always called a break up as opposed to a suspension of mutual feelings. It’s ironic that the most volatile substance in the universe, human emotion, can only be described in absolutes, and at that, only in negative absolutes.
“So when did the problems start happening?”
It was obvious that the girl on the other end was reluctant to delve into the negatives. I had seen her crying a few days prior, obviously from this situation. As much as she probably didn’t want to admit it, the fact that she was calling me was obviously a call for help. Yet, despite how emotional this situation was, I couldn’t help but get the feeling that such emotions were over something miniscule. But that’s how it is with emotions, hills become mountains, and mountains become hills. The simplest things turn into the most difficult of situations, whilst the most difficult of situations can be overcome with the utmost of ease.
“Well, we got back from New York, and he started getting mad at me. He said I was acting too much like his girlfriend, was around him too much, and said that he didn’t want to be friends with me anymore…”
Just like that, it was obvious what the problem was. A class “A” example of the one sided relationship. The girl on the other side of the line had strong emotions for this guy, but he obviously wanted nothing to do with her. She probably knows in her heart that she will never get back together with this guy, but because she is so emotional over him, she’s going to give him every chance he can get before she calls it quits. A nasty situation, and one that is surprisingly painful for both sides, assuming that both ends at least have some form of a soul.
“…so any advice?”
I had taken a recent habit to playing the White Knight in regards to girls that I was attracted to. With the girl on the other end asking for my advice, I was all too ready to take up my cape, withdraw my sword, and play that part. Of course, I didn’t particularly like being the White Knight as I would much rather be involved with my own emotional mischief. But for whatever reason, playing the White Knight was something that I was good at, and at the very least, it kept me partially entertained while still giving me some chance with girls.
“Well I think it’s pretty obvious that you should move on”
“Move on!? I don’t want to move on, I just want to be his friend now, I don’t care if I’m his girlfriend or not, I just want to be his friend”
“Why do you just want to be his friend?”
“Because I love him, but not like that. I love him as a friend, and I would be emotionally crushed if he just stopped being my friend because of this”
I couldn’t help but find humor in the lie this girl was telling herself. No one connects love with friendship, in fact I would go so far as to say that love and friendship are oxymoronic in this context. The girl on the other end simply could not accept her feelings for this guy and could only justify them as being friend based, probably due to the negative connotations that I was talking about earlier. An obvious case of ignorance, and emotional immaturity, and the only way to snap the girl out of this was to tell her what she didn’t want to hear.
“I’ve never seen someone connect love and friendship so closely together… are you sure you don’t want to date this guy still?”
“YES! I just want to be friends…FRIENDS!”
She was still lying to herself, and it was obvious that she was never going to realize her lies. I turned my attention to “Girl Shy” as the main character was writing another chapter in his book. It started saying “When trying to get a flapper… use the caveman method”. I couldn’t help but take into consideration such advice. Maybe being a rough, abusive, caveman was more effective then floundering around as the White Knight.
“To be honest, I’ve been in both sides of this situation and here’s what’s going to happen. The guy obviously doesn’t have any mutual feelings for you. I don’t care how you look at it, but you have to realize that people aren’t so damn picky when it comes to being friends with someone. Besides, who gets pissed off when a girl who obviously likes them starts acting like their girlfriend? He’s just being a douchebag.”
“He’s a very fickle person”
“Fickle or not, it’s pretty damn obvious that he doesn’t have mutual feelings for you.”
My White Knight act was going a little tougher on the girl than I was hoping for it to be. I had been in this situation a ton of times, and could write a book of advice on how to directly handle such a scenario. What I was saying to the girl came out of life experience and truth. As much as I hoped my White Knight ploy would somehow get this girl for me, I couldn’t compromise such truthful advice for a chance at my own personal gain.
“Then where did I go wrong?”
The nasty component to this situation, when the neglected side begins thinking it’s their fault. The only logical thing to do is to tell that side that it isn’t their fault, which is what they want to hear. The problem is, even if you tell them that, in their hearts they won’t believe it, and truth be told, the fact that someone refuses to accept them is indirectly their fault.
“The thing is, you didn’t go wrong. People aren’t so judgmental, especially someone who was holding your hand a week ago. Unless this guy is super emotional, which he probably isn’t, then I’m going to guess that he’s just playing you.”
“Ahh this just so confusing, I just want to get everything resolved with him so I can at least move on either way.”
“And you’re going to give him every chance you can because you like him so much.”
“Do you think I’m being naïve?”
“Probably, but I would venture to say that love by definition is naïve, so there’s nothing you can do”
I once again turned my attention to “Girl Shy” expecting for this conversation to conclude. As the main character goes on tour for his newly released book, he finds himself sitting next to a beautiful girl. The main character tries to talk to her, but he has his crippling stutter. The girl notices his stutter, and thinking that it’s cute, she holds his hand. Instantly the main character overcomes his stutter, and clearly expresses his love and attraction for the girl sitting next to him. The girl blushes, and as the train reaches the train station, she quickly kisses him on the cheek before leaving. It was ironic, seeing as how the movie was exactly the opposite of the situation that I was tending to.
“Well, thanks for your advice tonight”
“No problem, I hope it helped.”
“Believe me it did”
“Next time I have girl problems I expect you to stay up until four thirty with me to talk about them”
“Haha, you bet your ass I will”
“Well good luck with all this, I hope it all works out…Goodnight”
“Thanks and have a goodnight also”
I hung up, it was four thirty, and I was beginning to get tired. I was lucky to catch the final minutes of “Girl Shy”. After reuniting with his long lost train lover, the main character romantically looks upon his girl. He whispers something romantic, stutter nonexistent, but inaudible due to the nature of the film. She looks up at him, smiles, embraces him, and they engage in a long kiss, as the scene gradually fades to credits. I laugh, realizing the antithesis of the two situations I experienced that night, and couldn’t help but wonder why I was still playing the White Knight. Then it dawned on me, I was girl shy.